I like my new replacement joysticks for the joy cons. They feel nice to use with pretty much the same feeling as the originals. The feeling when moving each joysticks feels like writing on paper, rather than the originals, which feels more like writing on ipad. However it has less resistance than the originals. The materials on these ones also feel a bit less rubbery than the originals which I like because the originals tend to get slippery when they get exposed to finger oils over time, although I don't know how these will hold in the long term yet. There were just a bit of quality control issues with my unit (I don't know how it is for others).
The original pair I received were faulty. One of them was fine but the other had issues when I dragged the joystick to the edge of the right side. It would kind of teleport to the opposite side back and forth at high speed, and when I moved it around in a large circle, it would sort of reverse back a bit at a point on the right side. Moreover with both of these, it would always be easier to press the joysticks on one side (on the left joystick it was easier to press it down when it was on the bottom, and on the right joystick it was easier to press it when it was on top). I contacted Gamory and Gulikit with no response back so far from either.
In the end I had to buy another pair and that ended up being great. These ones are more consistent and I will be using these ones for a very long time because of the Hall effect. I'm happy with the current pair but leaving a 3 star review for the quality control and service.